That's two, count them two, Judgement Covers. The Judgement Cover is the Holy version of the Judgement Helm that drops from Onyxia. Of course, I was the only Paladin in the raid. So I now have my healing helm from Ony.
This is really how loot worked at Level 60, and you have 40 people to try to get their Tier sets. Thank Blizzard for Tokens.